Worlds in Collision!!

What Happens when Global Warming, Economics and Politics Collide?

In the heady days last century when global warming was of gravest world concern, the Kyoto Protocol was passed at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). It went into effect on 12/11/1997.

Now, the rubber meets the road. London’s Financial Times reported yesterday that three worlds – economics, politics and global warming – have collided head on… and the clash of titans ain’t pretty!

The Kyoto Protocol

By November 2009, in a tsunami of idealism and imperative concern, the Kyoto Protocol was signed by 187 countries. The United States is the lone non-signing holdout.

Kyoto directs the so-called “Annex I” industrialized countries to take these actions:

  • Cut their own greenhouse gas emissions back to 1990 levels
  • Contribute (with Annex II) to a fund assisting undeveloped nations to fight global warming

It was ratified by enough Annex I countries to give it the authority of international law. The European Union is considered Annex I and it also ratified Kyoto.

Always concerned for the little guy, the U.N. excluded poorer emerging nations, called “non-Annex I” countries, from any restrictions on their greenhouse emissions. Noticeably present on the unrestricted list are China (#1 world polluter), India (#3), Iran (#8) and South Korea (#10). Also present on that list are the #11, #12, #13, #14 and #15 largest polluters in the world. #14 is Saudi Arabia.

BTW, the political brainiacs at Kyoto are also the numskulls who concocted the carbon credit trading scheme that allows buying/selling/trading of carbon credits so offenders can keep on polluting. They just pass the cost penalties on to affected business customers and taxpayers. In theory the money is used to develop clean, eco-friendly technologies. Yeah, right!

Anyone still wonder why the United States never signed it, yet? If so, keep reading.

 Global Warming Headbutts into China and Airplanes

The Financial Times reports that Airbus and six big European Airlines have banded together to try and delay plans by the European Union to force international air carriers to pay a carbon penalty for international flights.

They are OK with domestic carbon restrictions. They want the international restrictions put on hold.

The airlines sent letters to the heads of state of England, Germany, France and Spain. Those guys all ratified Kyoto.

They claim that implementing the restrictions on time will jeopardize billions of dollars in aircraft sales and cost 2,000 jobs. They called it an “intolerable” threat to the European aviation industry, saying it will trigger trade wars with China, the U.S. and Russia.

Airbus says that China is holding up $12 billion dollars in A330 long-haul jet orders because they don’t want to pay a pollution penalty.

Yup, that’s right! China! The same China that is the world’s #1 polluter, world’s #2 economy and that is already exempted from any pollution restrictions whatsoever. Now its refusing to pay a pollution penalty for flying into European airspace.


Several important events have happened since Kyoto was signed:

  • Mandatory greenhouse gas restrictions have been delayed
  • Canada became the first country to officially drop out of the protocol
  • The planet stopped warming

First round mandatory C02 and other greenhouse gas reductions were originally to go into full effect this year. That has been delayed 5 more years.

Canada denounced Kyoto in December 2011 and became the first, and probably not the last, to drop out of the protocol. Canada cites economic hardship and fairness reasons.

Ironically, about the time Koyto went into effect the planet stopped warming; that despite atmospheric C02 continues rising unabated.

The EU will probably cave on implementing carbon penalties on international flights. Money talks and Europe is already in a world of hurt financially. The U.N. has set a precedent by delaying Kyoto restrictions by 5 years already.

There are so many big polluting countries exempted from emission restrictions for political and economic reasons that its doubtful that whatever the Annex I countries do, it won’t be enough to make a diddly squat’s difference anyway.

When it comes to money and politics, global warming will lose out every time.


About azleader

Learning to see life more clearly... one image at a time!

Posted on Mar 12, 2012, in China, climate change, economics, eurozone, Global Warming, Kyoto Protocol, news, Opinion, Politics, science. Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.

    • Thanks, CiCi! I get things right every once in a while.

      Ya know, they say if you put a monkey in front of a keyboard long enough, he can write Shakespeare! lol!!!

  1. Is the tax that China refuses to pay for flights that travel over Europe, or a tax on Airbus planes itself? If the latter, then Boeing is a winner in the collision of the worlds.

    I think of issues as containing three P’s: P-politics\policy; P-pricing or economics; and P-physics or engineering. Among the three, Physics > Economics > Politics. And ignore at one’s peril. The best politics is that which has physics and economics as its foundation, otherwise it is just rhetorical garbage or idealism.

    Lastly, if the world has stopped warming per the physics, then econ world is going to win next big time, and Kyoto will be in the scrap heap.

    • The tax is for flying in European airspace in a C02 generating airplane, the A330. I doubt any existing airplane meets the standard.

      China is just trying to weasel as much out of Airbus as it can… like a lower cost per plane, for example.

      Carbon credit commodities is the dumbest ecological idea EVER!

      Btw… Kyoto is almost on the scrap heap right now… it’ll get there before the next hard date is reached… unless it is delayed again.

Comments and questions are welcomed!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: