Why Wisconsin Matters

Wisconsin’s gubernatorial recall election today isn’t just a weather vane showing campaign 2012’s wind direction. It has real and emotional repercussions that will rumble across America like an earthquake.

The recall will change state politics nationwide in fundamental ways long after the noise of November fades into nothingness.

It has crucial national politic implications, too. It:

  1. Addresses the #1 issue in campaign 2012 – jobs and the economy
  2. Challenges the collective bargaining process
  3. Challenges the size and scope of big government at all levels
  4. Pits core Republican fiscal values against core Democratic social values
  5. Challenges the power of unions to control elections
  6. Challenges the power of protest movements in shaping long-term public opinion

Today’s election results will leave an indelible marker on state and local politics nationwide that won’t wash off. How it is resolved will shape individual state fiscal policy everywhere for many years to come.

The National Setting

Because of the Great Recession, all 50 U.S. states face fiscal crises of epic proportions. Most states, like Wisconsin, require balanced budgets.

ARRA propped up state governments. It’s funding ran out at the end of 2010. That left most states with huge budget deficits for 2011 and beyond.

Public sector job losses the last two years are not in federal employment. No. All public job losses are at the state and local levels.

Wisconsin took a controversial path to solving their $3.6 billion budget shortfall without cutting jobs.

Why Was Scott Walker Elected in 2010?

Scott Walker was elected a fiscally conservative governor to combat a massive $3.6 billion deficit.

Though known as a democratic stronghold nationally, Walker’s mandate for change was stamped by Republican majorities voted into both statehouses. Why?

In an unprecedented landslide in 2010, Republicans nationwide were swept back into power. First, they won the U.S. House of Representatives.

For good or for ill, that win alone altered the national debate. Democrats lost invincible 2008 majorities.

Wisconsin got caught up in the maelstrom fomented by the Tea Party Movement.

The Tea Party Movement started with a set of nationwide protests on tax day – April 15th, 2009. It was ordinary Americans of every demographic revolting against big government spending and excessive taxation. It captured the mood of the nation.

The Tea Party’s biggest influence in 2010 was in state and local elections. Nationwide, 625 statehouse seats changed hands from Democratic to Republican control.

Walker was one of about 10 governorships grabbed away from Democrats by Republicans.

Scott Walker Creates a Firestorm

At the heart of Walker’s plan to close the budget shortfall was stripping away all public employee union collective bargaining rights except for salary.

Mostly it was to reel in burgeoning health care costs. Other states, like Oregon, resolved that issue within existing collective bargaining agreements.

Walker didn’t! To add insult to public union injury, his plan also rescinded the requirement that all public employees must pay union dues.

That triggered a firestorm of nationwide protest against union busting. Protesters by the 10s of thousands rallied in support of Wisconsin. They were held in every state in the United States. They were organized and otherwise funded by public unions like the SEIU, but also by uninvolved unions like the UAW and Teamsters who see themselves as threatened.

Fueled by emotional outrage and national union money, more than twice as many signatures as needed were gathered to force a recall election of Governor Walker and others.

Walker’s Approach Appears To Be Working

Whether you like it or not, Walker’s fiscal conservative approach to combat Wisconsin’s massive $3.6 billion budget deficit has been largely successful.

The worst case scenario has Wisconsin now facing a manageable $143 million budget deficit right now. Teachers and other unioned state employees were not massively fired. Walker even cut taxes.

Wisconsin’s state unemployment rate has dropped from 7.7% to an enviable 6.7% since Walker took office. According to the BLS, Wisconsin has added about 30,000 jobs into the state economy during Walker’s tenure.

President Obama could coast into a second term with Walker’s success.

Depending on their political persuasion, however, Wisconsin voters have chosen to either believe or disbelieve those facts in a hotly contested recall election.

Where Is President Obama?

A year ago, at the peak of national outrage over Walker limiting collective bargaining rights, President Obama said this at the National Governors Conference:

I don’t think anybody does any good when public employees are denigrated or vilified or their rights are infringed upon.
– President Obama, 3/5/2011, National Governor’s Conference

This year, in a tight race defending public employee rights, President Obama is AWOL.

The Daily Beast, which will never be accused of right-wing anything, took exception to Obama’s decision to avoid Wisconsin.

Apparently, campaign math drove Obama’s decision. Obama has a strong lead in Wisconsin. He chose not to jeopardize that lead and stand up for unions. It looks like a lost cause.

That decision will prove to be a lose-lose for the Obama campaign. Should Tom Barrett win, Democrats and unions will still remember Obama abandoned them. Should Tom Barrett lose today, and the polls say he will, Wisconsin Democrats and unions nationwide will be hard pressed to be enthusiastic for the President.

The President, however, did graciously Tweet support for Tom Barrett yesterday.

In the meantime, the only organizing effort in Wisconsin making national headlines was the Tea Party Movement quietly canvasing the state with a door-to-door, get-out-the-vote bus tour over the weekend.


Scott Walker is gonna win today. Nationally, Democrats and unions have all but waved a white flag.

Perhaps not all, but most of the other officials under recall today will win, too.

It won’t be because the Republican money machine bought the votes. It won’t be because national Democrats and unions abandoned support for Tom Barrett at the last minute. It won’t be because the Tea Party bus tour outflanked Democrats.

It will be because Scott Walker’s policies are working and Wisconsin voters know it.

As a result, State governments all over the nation will reshape their approach to budget deficit reduction. Scott Walker took the heat and won the war for them.

After today, Democrats will be floating a foundering ship into the November elections.


About azleader

Learning to see life more clearly... one image at a time!

Posted on Jun 5, 2012, in 2012 Elections, Barack Obama, culture, economics, Life, news, Opinion, Politics, Protests, Thoughts. Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. America needs Walker to win today!

    • Strangely, given all that has happened since 2010, I think Walker will win by about the same margin he won by against the same man two year ago… around +5%.

    • Results are in…
      Walker and his Lieutenant Governor have both survived recall elections in what looks to be landslides.

      I don’t know results from the other 4 State legislators in recall elections yet.

      No doubt about it, though… Democrats are in trouble in 2012.

      Final Note:
      Wisconsin had the largest number of recall elections in one term in U.S. history

      All told, in two separate elections, there were 12 recalls:
      1 Governor
      1 Lieutenant Governor
      10 State Legislators

      Net change in the two recall elections was that Democrats won 3 state legislature seats to win control of the State Senate.

  2. Living here, it is a relief that the recall season is over. Small cities, rural areas, and suburbs supported the Governor. The Big City, Milwaukee, and university towns, Madison, went against the Governor.

    This election shows a rift too in the Democratic coalition if exit polls are to be believed. 48% of folks belonging to private sector unions supported the Governor. Usually the Democrats get more than 52% support from the private sector unions. Not sure if this means unionism in America is ending, or the Democrat coalition is fracturing for some reason. Either theory bodes poorly for President Obama as you also indicated.

    The majority of folks want smaller state government, and Governor Walker is doing that. The public sees a Republican executive really committed to shrinking government, unlike Reagan or Bush W who said they were for small government, but the federal government just grew and grew still.

    In the Great Depression folks became liberal. In the high inflation of the 70s folks turned conservative. Now with the Great Recession you might expect folks turning more liberal, but very much contrary to previous American history, conservative policy is what the majority wants.

    We live in very interesting times where the old paradigms and explanations do not seem to work. Folks just do not like big Government period. Big government brought all kinds of programs and subsidies for everyone. It will be interesting to see if the trend to less government is just for less social activism and less income redistribution, or if it applies to all the subsidies businesses get.

    Having seen how Wall Street keeps getting bailed out by both parties, and no one on Wall Street goes to jail, I suspect the business subsidies will stick around as folks will liken them to assisting economic development and creating jobs, even if such things pit one state against another in recruiting new businesses.

    • You ‘Sconsinites have got to be war weary of recall and elective politics!

      But what happened in your state yesterday will be the shot heard around the nation’s statehouses.

      State and local governments have been hit hardest by the recession because of dwindling tax revenues. That is why public sector jobs are on the decline.

      But you have shown the nation you can control debt without people losing their jobs if everyone pitches in.

      Oregon had a similar $3+ billion deficit when, like Wisconsin, a new governor – John Kitzhaber – was elected in 2010. You’ve probably never heard of him.

      Kitzhaber did the same thing with the same results as Scott Walker, also without raising taxes.

      Nobody knows John Kitzhaber because he united Oregonians and solved its budget deficit from within the collective bargaining process.

Comments and questions are welcomed!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: