The ‘One Million Job’ Self-Deception

A question on every American voter’s mind is:
“Who will fix the economy and create the most jobs – President Obama or Mitt Romney?”

All other issues, though important, pale in comparison.

That was on everyone’s mind during last night’s 2nd presidential debate. The first question asked by college student Jeremy Epstein was how each candidate could assure him that “I will be able to sufficiently support myself after I graduate?”

College students are not the only ones asking about making a livable wage.

In answer to Jeremy’s question last night the first words of reassurance from President Obama were:

What I want to do is build on the 5 million jobs that we’ve created over the last 30 months in the private sector alone
– President Barack Obama, 2nd Presidential Debate, 10/17/2012

With these opening few words the President reveals his profound self-deception about the scope of the jobs crisis gripping this country. Prerequisite to curing the jobs problem, it is first necessary to understand its magnitude.

We are in a jobs depression. The President is in denial of it.

As stated above, President Obama’s denial has morphed into a one million job self-deception. 

The Jobs Depression

The jobs depression directly affects around 30 million American workers and their families.

It goes far beyond Jeremy Epstein’s immediate job prospects. It isn’t cured by making college more affordable.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), 23 million unemployed and underemployed Americans are seeking livable wages. The BLS says that unemployment rate stands at 14.7%. It is down 2.5 percentage points from two years ago, but that is no comfort to the 23 million families struggling to pay the bills.

Another 5 to 7 million more disillusioned American workers have lost their jobs and have simply given up seeking work all together.

Everyone knows the country is in a jobs depression. It is all around us. It is either in your own home now or your neighbor’s home. Just open your eyes, you’ll see it.

What 5 Million Jobs?

President Obama told Jeremy and America that he wants to build on the above mentioned 5 million jobs. It is the same thing he told America in the first presidential debate two weeks ago.

The President’s above statement ends with the word “alone”. That implies there are other gains as well. There aren’t.

The problem with the President’s claim is it simply is not supported by the facts. According to the BLS, there have been 4.6, not 5 million private-sector jobs created in the U.S. in the last 30 months.

Worse yet, instead of more job gains as the President implies, the rest of the economy outside the private-sector lost -518,000 jobs in the last 30 months.

That means there have been 4.1 million jobs created in the last 30 months instead of 5 million. That is a big difference.

Worse still, according to the BLS, most of the job gains last month that dropped the official unemployment rate to 7.8% were part-time jobs taken for “economic reasons”. In other words, people took part-time jobs because they were desperate, probably because all their unemployment benefits had run out.

The President has convinced himself he has created a million more new jobs than actually exist.

Never mind that the private-sector created the few jobs there actually are. Private-sector growth results more from the efforts of hard working Americas and entrepreneurs than government economic policy.


We are in a jobs depression.

New job creation over the last 30 months has averaged +136,000/month. That is barely the rate expected from population growth. Worker victims of the mortgage bubble collapse in 2008 have not found jobs. They have been left behind and ignored.

Nothing very helpful has been done to create jobs for long-term displaced workers who lost their jobs in the Great Recession through no fault of their own. The lucky ones retired. The rest, sadly, just dropped out of the workforce because they can’t find work. Their marketable skills have rusted away like America’s empty factories.

Jeremy Epstein will soon join their ranks when he graduates from college if things continue as they are.

Yet the President doesn’t seem to get it. He has convinced himself things are better than they are. He has convinced himself the little that he is doing now is enough to recover the economy and miraculously create jobs for all who need them. It isn’t.

President Obama wants to stay the course. Can you and Jeremy afford to wait for it to work?


About azleader

Learning to see life more clearly... one image at a time!

Posted on Oct 17, 2012, in 2012 Elections, culture, economics, Job Creation, Jobs, Life, news, Opinion, Politics, Thoughts. Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Reblogged this on yasniger and commented:
    Indeed the question on every American voter’s mind yesterday, today & for the next few weeks leading to the election is:
    “Who will fix the economy and create the most jobs – President Obama or Mitt Romney?” All other issues, though important, are pale in comparison.

    Some one should wake America up…. America is in a jobs depression & the President is in denial of it.

    • You are welcomed to repost as long as its accurate, its meaning isn’t distorted and/or its not claimed as your own.

      You met those criteria and restated my theme better than I said it myself.

      • Thanks for the wordpress provisions, I find that I don’t need to bother myself with any editing. I reblog as I find them in your original post.

        I reblog what I enjoy & want my own readers to also see.
        Thanks for the chance to share your posts.

        Be safe & keep up the good work

  2. “Prerequisite to curing the jobs problem, it is first necessary to understand its magnitude.”

    I don’t know if the president is in denial or he wants to con the public. But the first step in solving any problem to admit there is a problem.

    • I think the President really believes what he is doing is right for the country. He believes it so strongly that it has transformed his perceptions. That is why he believes his job creation record is better than it is.

    • No offense, I shouldn’t be one to talk given I’m no economist either, but I’m hoping you weren’t an economics instructor in your teaching career. Things may be just a wee bit more complex than that, methinks. 😉

  3. The Main Stream Media should quit slanting the fact. This is not the Great Recession nor the Greatest Recession, but a full blown JOBS DEPRESSION, the first since the 1930s; and federal policy seems to think muddling along is good enough. With such low expectations we are doomed. There is so much work to be done in this country. Bulldoze all the empty builidngs is a simple one, get rid of the blight. I could go on and on.

    • Something dramatic has changed in the last two recessions. It includes the 2001-2003 recession and now the 2008 recession. I don’t know why.

      But in both cases they have been longer and flatter than previous recessions and are characterized by the lack of jobs.

      The term “jobless recovery” was first coined by economists during the 2001-2003 recession.

      Perhaps it has something to do with globalization where businesses shed expensive American jobs for cheaper foreign ones in order to weather the recession and then those jobs just never come back in order to remain competitive in world markets.

  1. Pingback: The “5.2 Million Job” Invention « Inform The Pundits!

  2. Pingback: Job Creation and President Obama « Inform The Pundits!

Comments and questions are welcomed!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: