Uneasy Gaza Peace Worth a Try

It likely will turn out to be temporary, like so many other peace treaties in the Middle East since 1946, but the Gaza ceasefire appears to be holding…
for now.

The best news is that both Israel and Gaza are claiming victory.

That is usually an indication that the right balance between two warring parties has been reached. That also means there will be continuing mistrust between them unless long-term peace can finally be achieved. There is no sign of that happening yet. This is another chapter in a long saga of unrest.

What sets this agreement apart is that a new Egypt and the United States worked cooperatively together to get the respective sides they support – Egypt through Hamas and the U.S. through Israel – to agree to a cessation of hostilities.

It could be claimed it is the direct result of the Arab Spring and President Obama’s express foreign policy of negotiating with your enemies without preconditions.

Both Morsi of Egypt and Obama of the U.S. deserve the lion’s share of credit for this latest brokered deal. Each made secret deals with their respective protectorates that got them to agree.

Morsi gets the most credit because, for the first time, a Middle East deal was worked out by a democratically elected Mideast leader representing the middle east people rather than the interests of a dictator or the West.

That is an important change made possible by the Arab Spring and the democratization of Egypt.

The U.S. restrained Israel from a full-scale ground invasion of Gaza on the promise we would help prevent smuggling of more missiles into Gaza and provide continuing military aid for the Iron Dome defense system. Nobody knows what Egypt promised Hamas, but it must have been substantial and/or Gaza was running out of long range missiles. The U.S. probably promised Egypt further aid, too.

Hamas, for the first time, can claim it has been taken seriously by the international community. From this time forward, Hamas could chose to put their greatest energy into making better the lives of the 1.7 million Palestinians under their control, but probably will not. Guns, missiles, violence and scapegoating Israel is the only life they know.

Such as it is, this latest approach to solving Middle East intractable differences has achieved a shaky success. The Arab Spring can claim victory in its first major test of Arab-Israeli conflict.

Morsi has assumed center stage. Will he use his new-found stature for the good of the movement or for his own good? Given that he is taking steps to consolidate his own power, that remains to be seen.

In the end, Gaza will rearm with more long-range missiles and more weapons using technology smuggled in from the outside that the U.S. and Israel cannot stop. Hamas will lack the discipline and statesmanship to refrain from using them and then the missiles will start raining again and the Mideast will slip back into the familiar pattern of violence begetting violence.

Giving peace a chance, however, is never the wrong move. No matter what the reasons, it holds a tiny sliver of hope that, this time, things will be different.


About azleader

Learning to see life more clearly... one image at a time!

Posted on Nov 23, 2012, in culture, Gaza, Life, Middle East, news, Opinion, Politics, Thoughts. Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. The peace won’t last, AZ. I am not an expert on the history of the area once known as Palestine. From what I have read, there was never a nation recognized by any other nation called Plestine. The region was home to many tribes including the Plestinians and the Jews. Prior to 1948 the Palestinian region was under the governance of Great Britain. In 1948 by a UN resolution the area was partitioned to the Jews and the Plestenians. The Jews accepted and the Palestenians did not. The argued that all the territory was theirs and that is the problem still today. Hamas claims they are not terroist attacking Israel; but that they have a right to attack Israel because they are fighting for their homeland. How does anyone ever solve that conflict?

    • If I’m not mistaken, nobody cared about a Palestinian state before 65 years ago or so. Before the British they were under the dominion of the Ottoman Empire for about 400 years or so before WWI.

      I suspect you are right… this is just another temporary lull… maybe even a very temporary one… but the common Arab in Egypt now has a type of commitment to the peace process that perhaps they have never felt before and that may make a difference in the long term.

      That is assuming, of course, that Morsi doesn’t morph into another dictator.

Comments and questions are welcomed!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: