Facts and fallacy in “Years of Living Dangerously”

“Years of Living Dangerously” image shows arid but not drought-stricken area

Showtime premiered James Cameron’s “Years of Living Dangerously” on Sunday. It’s a big-budget documentary series about climate change. Anyone can watch episode one for free on YouTube.

Virtually everything said about climate change these days mixes fact with fiction. This series is no exception. The first episode stars Harrison Ford, Don Cheadle and Pulitzer Prize winning New York Times reporter Thomas L. Friedman.

The list of Hollywood luminaries behind the series is long and distinguished. The opening credits list 25 executive producers and co-producers. They include Jerry Wientraub, James Cameron, Arnold Swartzwenegger, Daniel Assasi, Joel Bach, David Gelber and billionaire Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen, among many others.

Episode one starts off like a scene from Top Gun with Harrison Ford flying in a fighter jet that collects greenhouse gas samples. It goes on to present three humanized climate change stories.

Harrison Ford investigates deforestation in Indonesia. Don Cheadle investigates the impact of a drought-closed meat packing plant in Plainview, Texas. Thomas L. Friedman slips across the border into war-torn Syria to investigate if drought triggered its civil war.

Basic Facts

Is climate change real? Yes. Climate has been changing for billions of years. It’s not going to stop now.

Is global warming real? Yes. Is human-cause CO2 rising? Yes. Is CO2 a greenhouse gas? Yes. Have there been “increases in intensity and/or duration of drought”? No. Have there been “increases in intense tropical cyclone (hurricane) activity”? No. Has global land-sea temperatures risen in the last 15 years? No.

Some may disagree, but that’s what the IPCC says in its newest AR5 report released last September.

Deforestation is a serious human-caused disaster. It contributes 20 percent of all atmospheric CO2 emissions, according to interviewed scientists in the first episode. Losing large swaths of tropical rain forest ecosystems in Indonesia and South America is threatening the extinction of vast numbers of plant and animal species.

Fiction

IPCC Summary for Policymakers: Drought and hurricanes not yet affected by global warming

The two climate stories about drought blame them on human-induced climate change. That directly contradicts the assessment of the IPCC in their new report.

The IPCC has “low confidence” that past and current droughts have resulted from human-caused global warming. Not only that, but the IPCC says global warming won’t affect drought or hurricanes until late this century!

Claiming that droughts last longer and are more intense today because of CO2 emissions is not supported by the IPCC.

Have droughts triggered human hardship and social unrest? Yes. The demise of ancient Mesoamerican civilizations and the pueblo cultures of the southwestern United States are blamed on drought.

The Texan and Syrian droughts were bad, but not extraordinary.

The “Dust Bowl” droughts of the 1930s produced dust storms so big some blew all the way to New York City. That drought triggered a mass westward migration of displaced tenant farmers immortalized in John Steinbeck’s epic novel, “The Grapes of Wrath“.

Fifty eight percent of all existing state record high temperatures in the United States were set in the 1930s and 1910s. The highest temperature ever recorded on earth is 134°F set July 10, 1913 in Death Valley, California.

Climate deniers

An unfortunate series misstep stigmatizes fundamentalist Christians as ignorant climate deniers.

Texas Tech climate scientist Dr. Katharine Hayhoe, herself a Christian that converted her minister husband from climate naysayer to human-caused believer, is presented as a crusading scientist that goes around drought-stricken Texas converting the uninformed into enlightened believers.

A future segment called “The Preacher’s Daughter” in an upcoming episode will continue the negative stereotyping.

Conclusions

James Cameron’s new climate change series “Years of Living Dangerously” is very engaging. It uses Hollywood-generated drama narrated by big name celebrities to document the human effects of extreme weather.

Harrison Ford’s segment on deforestation is very eye-opening to anyone unfamiliar with what’s happening to earth’s rain forests.

Unfortunately, the other two segments on drought exchange scientific accuracy for alarmist rhetoric. They humanize drought effects very well but, quite frankly, what is presented is no different from what’s been happened naturally throughout human history.

Cameron, contrary to IPCC findings, erroneously links both droughts to human-induced climate change.

It’s hard to decide which is worse, enlightened misinformation or ignorant misinformation.

Advertisements

About azleader

Learning to see life more clearly... one image at a time!

Posted on Apr 14, 2014, in Climate, climate change, culture, environment, Global Warming, IPCC, Life, nature, news, Opinion, Politics, science, Thoughts. Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. Thank you for showing Hollywood’s and Christian extremists’ contribution to our government’s propaganda mill.

    As old propaganda is discredited, new propaganda is produced. The goal is always the same. To show that our political leaders control the Earth and it’s bounty !

    • It’s my belief that the Hollywood elite behind the new Showtime series “Years of Living Dangerously” really and truly believe in their cause.

      It’s just that they accepted the AGW world view long ago that it is “settled science”.

      They haven’t kept up with scientific finds and stopped applying critical thinking to what they hear and see.

      That is how a project back by a mountain of money makes the unsupported claim in two segments that current droughts are caused by global warming even though the IPCC says otherwise.

      It’s unfortunate they chose to stigmatize a entire group of people in ordered to demonstrate their supposed intellectual superiority.

      Let the data speak for itself. AGW theory will stand or fall on its own. Belittling people that don’t agree with your position detracts from any cause.

  2. The great fact is just this.

    Different religions over recorded history taught the same empirical fact: Human inhabitants of planet Earth will work together or die separately !

    There is no middle ground.

    That is why I requested an explanation from the Congressional Space Science & Technology Committee:

    WHY ? : https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/10640850/WHY.pdf

Comments and questions are welcomed!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: